US Packaging EPR series · Video 3

Am I the Producer? US Packaging EPR Explained

For brand owners, private-label retailers, licensees and importers: understand who counts as the producer under US packaging EPR. We compare state producer hierarchies, including California's SB 54, through four common setups: contract manufacturing, private label, reselling another company's brand, and foreign brands sold through a US importer.

States covered: California, Oregon, Colorado, Washington, Minnesota, Maryland and Maine.

Chapters

  1. Who is the producer, and why it matters(0:00)
  2. How each state defines the producer(0:38)
  3. Situation 1: contract manufacturing(1:34)
  4. Maryland and Oregon work differently(2:13)
  5. Situation 2: private label(2:38)
  6. Situation 3: reselling other brands(3:16)
  7. Situation 4: foreign brands and US importers(3:38)
  8. Online sellers: who owns the shipping box(4:25)
  9. Three questions to check yourself(4:56)
  10. Quick check: Minnesota assignment agreement(5:25)
  11. Not a clean answer? Next steps(5:48)

Transcript

Who is the producer, and why it matters

Your brand. Another factory. Who is the producer? Seven states. Four situations. Three questions. Why it matters. The producer is the company that joins the producer responsibility organization — the PRO, the nonprofit that runs the program — reports its packaging, and pays the fees. If you assume it's your manufacturer, and your manufacturer assumes it's you, nobody files. One caveat: being the producer is the first question, not the last. Small producers can be exempt, and some packaging is excluded — that's a separate check.

How each state defines the producer

The core test is the brand — but each state gets there its own way. Maryland, Minnesota, Washington and Maine use a ladder: first a manufacturer selling under its own brand, then a licensee allowed to make and sell under someone else's brand, then the brand owner. In Colorado, the rule puts the brand owner that directs the manufacturing first. In Oregon, the rule treats whoever directs the manufacturing — including setting the packaging specifications — as the manufacturer.

In California, it's the manufacturer that owns the brand, or holds an exclusive license for it, if it's in the state; if not, the brand owner; if the owner isn't in the state, its exclusive licensee if that licensee is in the state; and only then whoever sells the product into California. Different wording, one practical starting point: whose name is on the package, and who decides what the packaging is.

Situation 1: contract manufacturing

Situation one: contract manufacturing. A co-packer makes your product, buys the boxes, runs the line. In the usual setup you are still the producer, because you own the brand and you set the specifications. Oregon's rule says it directly: a manufacturer includes a person that directs the manufacturing, including setting specifications for the packaging. Outsourcing the work does not move the obligation by itself.

Maine, Minnesota and Washington do allow a signed agreement that assigns it to someone else — but only if that party joins the PRO and the PRO receives written certification of the agreement.

Maryland and Oregon work differently

Maryland and Oregon work differently. In Maryland, you're not the producer if, under an agreement, another company takes on responsibility for your packaging by written certification under a PRO program. Oregon works through registration. If another company registers with the PRO as the producer for a product, you don't pay fees on that product. And if that covers everything you sell into Oregon, you don't have to join the PRO.

Situation 2: private label

Situation two: private label. When a retailer sells a product under its own store brand, the retailer is usually the brand owner — and in the typical setup, that puts the obligation on the retailer, not on the factory. The check is the license. In Maine, Maryland, Minnesota and Washington, a manufacturer licensed to make and sell under your brand comes before the brand owner. And in Oregon, Circular Action Alliance's guidance says a brand owner that only licenses its name, without directing production, leaves the obligation with the manufacturer. Read the agreement.

Situation 3: reselling other brands

Situation three: reselling other people's brands. Buying finished products and putting them on your shelf does not, by itself, make you the producer — Oregon's rule says so in one line. But watch California: if neither the brand owner nor an exclusive licensee is in the state, the obligation can fall to whoever sells the product into California.

Situation 4: foreign brands and US importers

Situation four: foreign brands and importers. In California, being "in the state" has a legal meaning — roughly, whether you can be served and sued in California, or have registered as a producer and formally consented to California jurisdiction. A foreign brand with no presence there may well not be in the state, so the obligation can move down to whoever first sells or distributes the product in California — often the US importer.

In Oregon, Maryland, Minnesota and Washington, the importer steps in when no one higher up the ladder is within the United States; Maine asks whether they have a physical presence in the US. If you bring a foreign brand into the US, assume you may be the producer until you've checked.

Online sellers: who owns the shipping box

One more twist for online sellers. In six states — Oregon, Colorado, Maryland, Minnesota, Washington and Maine — the shipping box is treated separately from the product package. Its producer is whoever packs the item for the consumer; Oregon says packs and ships, Colorado says packs or ships. So if a fulfillment company packs your orders, the shipping box may not be yours. The product package follows the ladder we just walked through — and that one is usually yours.

Three questions to check yourself

Three questions to check yourself. One: whose brand is on the package, and does anyone hold a license to make and sell under it? Two: who sets the packaging specifications? Three: does that company pass the location test in each state's ladder — "in the state" in California, "within the United States" or "physical presence" elsewhere? If the answers point to you, you are very likely the producer. Then check exemptions and deadlines.

Quick check: Minnesota assignment agreement

Minnesota. Pine and Table is the producer. Both companies sign an assignment agreement. The receiving company joins a registered PRO. But Pine and Table never provides written certification to the PRO. Are all the assignment conditions met? No. Pine and Table must also provide written certification of the agreement to the PRO.

Not a clean answer? Next steps

If your answer isn't clean — imports, licensing, private label, several brands — that's exactly what we sort out at Orbitlex. Start with the free Status Check. The link is in the description. Or book a brief, free consultation with one of our specialists at orbitlex.com. This video explains the law as written. It isn't legal advice for your company.

Sources

Laws and rules cited

PRO guidance (Circular Action Alliance)

Information current as of October 2026.

This video provides general information about packaging EPR. It is not legal advice for your company. Laws, rules and program requirements change; check the current requirements for your company with the relevant state regulator or a qualified advisor.